Facebook and Google Earth: Anti-Semitism in Web 2.0

Antisemitismus im Web 2.0

Facebook and Google Earth

Anti-Semitism in Web 2.0

Facebook and Google Earth: Anti-Semitism in Web 2.0

Introduction:

Originally published as: Christoph Gunkel, Facebook und Google Earth: Antisemitismus im Web 2.0, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ), Germany, 14 October 2008. This translation, created for Zionism On The Web, has been aproved by the author and publisher and is hosted here with their consent. Please note this translation may not be reproduced without permission. The original article in German is available here.

The author: Christoph Gunkel is a German journalist. He is writing, among others, for "sueddeutsche.de", Munich, "Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung", Frankfurt and "Der Spiegel Special", Hamburg. He has also worked in the Department of History at ZDF, Germany's largest broadcasting television station. Mr Gunkel studied Journalism, History and Political Sciences in Germany and France.

The translator: Ricarda Krenn is a PhD candidate in Contemporary History at Graz University, Austria. She has studied in England, Scotland and Austria and holds a Masters in Historical Research and a BA (Honours) from Lancaster University. She is fluent in German, English, French and Spanish.

Copyright notice

The original German Language version of this article is © Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. All rights reserved. This translation was created for Zionism On The Web. For copyright requests please contact the Frankfurter Allgemeine Archive.

The translated article:

It was the massacre of seven youths and one adult that turned David into an internet warrior.

In March a Palestinian radical killed eight students of a Yeshiva, a Jewish religious school, in Jerusalem. Little later, Ahmad from Saudi Arabia founded a group on the online network Facebook, praising the murderer Alaa Abu Dhaim as a martyr. Before long, it had about three hundred members. For David, himself a Facebook member for several years, this was a ‘key moment’, leading him to increasingly seek public attention and ‘give a similarly clear answer’.

Together with like-minded friends, he founded the website ‘Jewish Internet Defence Force’ (JIDF), its name an allusion to the Israeli army, the ‘Israel Defence Force’. The JIDF’s logo is as martial as its name: a fighter jet in front of the blue-white Israeli flag with the Star of David.

The site’s goal is to act specifically against online antisemitism and anti-Israeli hate tirades in Web 2.0 – in popular social networks such as Facebook, Wikipedia or YouTube.

The work has its price: after several death threats, David doesn’t want to give any information about himself other than his first name. For years, he and his comrades-in-arms had watched the ‘rising tide of anti-Semitism’ and had started various political campaigns – now they want to combine them in a high-publicity way under the mantle of the JIDF.

The usual anti-Semitic conspiracy theories

The JIDF claims to have five thousand supporters; it searches for anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic propaganda, reports it to the provider, urges other users to do the same and exerts pressure by involving the public. Since this does not always work, the JIDF also has ‘other means’, as David nebulously hints. Be that as it may, the JIDF claims to be have been successful in ‘infiltrating and destroying dozens of Facebook groups’. The biggest of these was alleged to have had 118.000 members and advertised the Shiite Hezbollah. Even today its old start page can be found on Facebook, but now the Logo of the JIDF proudly adorns it – and the old contents are no longer available.

The Near East-conflict finds its political and ideological continuation in the popular internet forums of Web 2.0. This poses great problems for the social networks, which are in themselves conceived as apolitical, since they are misused as propaganda platforms. Thus one finds on Facebook groups pictures of Hamas-fighters, dead Palestinian babies or children who pose in mock suicide vests. In an innumerable number of comments users from all over the world assert that ‘we all hate Israel’, that the country is ‘a terrorist state’, ‘the cancerous tumour of the Near East, a disease which we must destroy.’ Siet from Egypt, for example, asks: ‘Where will you go, Israel?? The sea in front of you, the Arabs behind you.’ The usual anti-Semitic conspiracy theories aren’t missing either: The Jews control the media, the world, American foreign policy – and the Holocaust did not take place as we believe. Those who do believe in the Holocaust praise Adol Hitler (‘That man burned your people to death!’) or point to Hitler-groups on Facebook. One of the largest is called ‘We respect you Hitler’ and currently has 357 members. There is even a group of 151 members whose cause is the denial of the Holocaust.

Snowballing

Of course there are counter-movements, the JIDF alone has twelve subsidiary groups. And there are violent outbursts by Jewish or Israeli users as well. ‘All Palestinians are murderers who kill little children’, claims one Israeli woman. And Johnny from London sees Mecca and Medina as originally having been ‘Jewish cities’ and places the entire Muslim world, which ‘only contributes to war and hatred’ in the darkest Middle Ages. ‘You animals, what have you ever given the world apart from oil?’

Facebook is the biggest social networking site in the world; according to its own claims, it has more than a hundred million active users and is the fourth-most visited website on the net. Messages snowball here. As soon as someone joins a hate-group, all their friends are informed about it. ‘Had Facebook existed in the times of Hitler’s ascent, the Nazis would probably have made use of it’, says the Australian computer scientist Andre Oboler who is working on a book about ‘Anti-Semitism 2.0’. ‘The top-sites on the net are search engines or Web 2.0-sites. Hatred can spread there.’

Facebook remained silent – for a year and a half

Oboler, who describes himself as a modern Orthodox Jew, fears that the online social networking sites could cause a ‘new global wave of anti-Semitism’ and ‘heighten the social acceptance of anti-Semitism’.

What is new is the speed with which classical anti-Semitism spreads via YouTube-clips, social networking sites or Wikipedia-articles. Most providers currently lack ‘the competence for an appropriate response’.

In Oboler’s view, Facebook should also ‘take more initiative on its own accord’. Over 48.000 members joined a group called ‘Israel is not a country!’ which cynically urged Facebook to delete Israel from the system’s country menu and spread hate-filled rants on their forum. In spite of many complaints, Facebook didn’t act for a year and a half. But the protest grew from within. A large counter-group was founded, strongly supported by the JIDF, which has over 67.000 members today. It urged Facebook to delete the group ‘Israel is not a country!’ – in early September, Facebook gave in.

Hate-filled sermons is allowed as long as nobody is being threatened

In the short-lived world of the Web, this win for the JIDF only lasted for a few mouse clicks. ‘The Zionists have taken over the old group, so we have founded a new one of the same name. If they destroy this one as well, we will create another, and another, and another.’ But those in charge of the new ‘Israel is not a country’-group are careful to aver that ‘this groups strongly condemns racism’. By now there are several groups of the same name with thousands of members – and counter-groups, who now complain that Facebook users can give ‘Palestine’ as their home country, ‘even though there is no state of Palestine’.

The groups grow faster than Facebook can shut them down – or wants to shut them down. Facebook’s own guidelines do prohibit the dissemination of contents, which Facebook deems ‘threatening, unlawful, inflammatory, vulgar or racist’. But asked about the anti-Israel groups, a spokeswoman reacts with a moral tightrope act. Facebook takes its guidelines ‘very seriously’ and reacts ‘quickly’ to abuse. Groups that threaten violence or are supported by terror organisations are closed. ‘We do not, however, take down groups that speak out against countries, political entities, or ideas.’ The aim is a ‘very delicate balance’ of freedom of speech and the users’ need for security. In other words: Hate-filled sermons are all right as long as nobody is threatened. But even so, Facebook doesn’t always stick to its own guidelines, even in unequivocal cases such as that of the group ‘Hamas Fan’ (1.300 members) which has existed since May. And the question of what Facebook intends to do about a group of Holocaust deniers, which has existed since July 2007, is discreetly left unanswered in the written statement by a company spokeswoman.

From fighters against online-hatred to anti-Islamism

Google Earth has followed a far clearer policy. If one visits Israel on Google Earth, one used to find there, until recently, a mess of orange dots: markings indicating Arab villages which Israel allegedly destroyed in the 1948 war – these are not-verifiable by lay people. Each orange dot was linked to the site palestineremembered.com. Google Earth has now deleted the links.

The JIDF follows an open political agenda as well. Many of its members protested the clearing of Israeli settlements in the Gaza strip in 2005 – they regard this policy of trading Land for Peace as wrong. Ultimately the JIDF also wants to propagate ‘Jewish values on the Internet’. This leads to the self-appointed warriors against online-hatred to link their own homepage to a dubious site named ‘thereligionofpeace.com’. The name is pure sarcasm. The site portrays Mohammad as a supporter of murder and paedophilia, draws a picture of Islam as a religion of hatred and compares it to the Ku-Klux-Klan or the Spanish Inquisition – with a clear result: Islam is much worse.

And sometimes even David loses his countenance as he tilts at the windmills of propaganda: ‘You are sick,’ he writes on Facebook to Ahmad from Saudi Arabia who brags about having devoted a group to the murderer of the Yeshiva-students – and who later provocatively joined one of the counter-groups which protested against it. ‘Get out of here,’ writes David angrily. ‘You terrorist-celebrating, disgusting pig!’

Related articles

More articles on antisemitism:

Under attack in a virtual world

By Andre Oboler, PresenTense Magazine, Febuary 2010.

Report from the Working Group on Online Antisemitism

By Andre Oboler and David Matas (Eds), The Global Forum to COmbat Antisemitism, December 2009, Jerusalem.

Facebook, Holocaust Denial, and Anti-Semitism 2.0

By Andre Oboler, The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 15 September 2009. This is the detailed report (published online in August 2009).

'Facebook doesn't bar hateful content against Jews'

By Elan Miller, Jerusalem Post, 27 August 2009

Holocaust Denial: Yes Facebook, it is Hate Speech

By Andre Oboler, Z-Word Blog, 27 August 2009.

Facebook gives hatred a hand

By Andre Oboler, Comment is Free at the Guardian, 13 July 2009

Facebook refuses to ban all Holocaust-denial groups

By Chantal Abitbol, The Australian Jewish News, 15 May 2009, pg 8

Antisemitism and the rise of a new world order? Obama’s inauguration

By Clemens Heni, Zionism On The Web, Febuary 7, 2009

Iran, Holocaust denial and PressTV

By Andre Oboler, Zionism On The Web Special Report, December 4 2008

Expert Warns on Internet antisemitism

By Sharon Berger, The Australian Jewish News, October 31 2008, pg 4

10 Questions for Dr Andre Oboler

The Australian Jewish News, October 31 2008, Life pg 16

Facebook and Google Earth: Anti-Semitism in Web 2.0

By Christoph Gunkel and translated into English by Ricarda Krenn. Originaly Published in German as Christoph Gunkel, Facebook und Google Earth: Antisemitismus im Web 2.0, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ), Germany, 14 October 2008.

Goldsmiths, Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto

By Jonathan Hoffman, Open Letter, Nov 13th 2008

"But I am a Zionist!"

By Clemens Heni, Zionism On The Web, Nov 3rd 2008

Good news in the fight against online hate

By Andre Oboler, Zionism On The Web, Sept 11, 2008. Original Draft (in English) of "Hatred and Antisemitism Online", Agencia Judia Noticias

Hatred and Antisemitism Online

By Andre Oboler, Agencia Judia Noticias (Jewish News Agency - Argentina), Sept 4 2008

Online Antisemitism 2.0, Social Antisemitism on the Social Web

By Dr Andre Oboler, The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, March / April 2008

Anti-Semitism 2.0 Going Largely Unchallenged

By Tamar Snyder, The New York Jewish Week, Febuary 20 2008

A false prospectus on campus

By Dr Andre Oboler, The Guardian, Comment is Free, February 15 2008

Facebook antisemitism: Facing the Facebook Dilemma

By Dr Andre Oboler, Jerusalem Post, 6th February 2008

Abusing the Holocaust

By Prof Gerald Steinberg, NGO-Monitor

UK's NUS accepts EU Definition of Antisemitism

By Andre Oboler, A ZOTW Special

European Union Definition of Antisemitism

This is the definition used throughout Europe by law enforcement

Antisemitism or anti-semitism?

By Andre Oboler, a ZOTW Special

Where Europe Fails

By Prof Gerald Steinberg, Jerusalem Post, 9 May 2007

Hitler's Legacy: Islamic Antisemitism in the Middle East

By Dr Matthias Küntzel, a German political scientist and author

The New Antisemitism

By Sir Jonathan Sacks, Chief Rabbi of the British Commonwealth of Nations. Read comments or add your own on the New Antisemitism forum.

What's New In Anti-Semitism?

By Azmi Bishara (Arab-Israeli MK), Dar Al-Hayat, November 20, 2003

The U.N. discovers the cause of anti-Semitism: Jews

By ANNE BAYEFSKY, Opinion Journal, November 18, 2004

Aren't Arabs Semites too?

Analysis of the propoganda that Arabs are semites too and hence can't be antisemitic

Language as a Tool against Jews and Israel

By Prof. Georges-Elia Sarfati, a French linguistics expert

Muslim antisemitism and anti-Zionism explained

By Dr Denis M. MacEoin, an expert in Islamic studies

Top articles in the Antisemitism Forum Archive



You can visit our full collection for more articles on Zionism, Israel and Palestine

External article links

Arabs and antisemitism

The Wikipedia article on Arabs and antisemitism

"Jew"

A Zionism Israel Information Center article on antisemitism and the Jews

External sites about antisemitism

The Coordination Forumfor Countering Antisemitism

The Anti-Defamation League

JAFI resources on Antisemitism

Middle East Antisemitism

International Center for the Study of Antisemitism At the Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Key references

The following may help you identify antisemitism and other types of racism

EU definition of antisemitism

Used by law enforcement throughout Europe

Behind much criticism of Israel is a thinly veiled hatred of Jews

Emanuele Ottolenghi, in The Guardian on Saturday November 29, 2003

A New Antisemitism

Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks, June 2002

Blurring the line

Fair critisism or antisemitism? By Abraham H. Foxman, National Director of the Anti-Defamation League (the ADL), in Haaretz on April 4, 2004

Antisemitism in 3-D

Differentiating legitimate criticism of Israel from the so-called new anti-Semitism. By Natan Sharansky in Jerusalem Post, on February 23, 2004

Anti-Zionism

What is Anti-Zionism?

Disagreeing with the policies of the Israeli government is in and of itself neither Antisemitic nor Anti-Zionist.

Even outside of this Anti-Zionism is not always Antisemitism, but many of those who claim to be anti-Zionist are in fact in fact peddling re-badged Antisemitism.

Our reference center can help you understand Anti-Zionism

Features include:





Zionism On The Web Directory

Learn more about this site at our Zionism Main page. Comment and add your thoughts to our Zionism and Israel discussion forums. See our Resource Centers on the British Academic Boycott of Israel, and the Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism Resource Center, and the special section on the Palestinian state. Learn more from our articles on Zionism in the commentary collection. Extend your learning through out links about Zionism or at our Zionism links directory.


External links on Israel and Zionism

If you found this site helpful, please tell others about Zionism and Israel on the Web and link to us at http://www.zionismontheweb.org

We'll be happy to add a link to our directory for any site on Israel, Zionism, the Middle East, or Judaism that links to us. You can add your site and if you have a link to us we'll aprove it. You can aslo e-mail us at for an additional link on our links page.

We also work closely with webmaster at the following sites:
Information about Israel and Zionism at http://www.zionism-israel.com

The Zionism Pages at http://www.zionism.netfirms.com

Zionism, Israel and me at www.zionism.me.uk

Recommended sources on Israel

Israel is a small, high tech, democratic country in the Middle East. It's capital Jerusalem is central to Judaism and highly important to Christianity and Islam. We recommend the following sites:

Wikipedia article about Israel - A comprehensive article including the history of Israel
Israel - Table of contents at the Jewish Virtual Library

US Library of congress & CIA World Fact Book on Israel
Main article on Israel - US Library of Congress
The Israeli Parliment (the Knesset) - US Library of Congress
Government and Politics of Israel - US Library of Congress
World Facts: Israel

Israel today - beyond the conflict
Virtual Jerusalem
Israel21C - A focus beyond the conflict
Beyond Images




(c) Zionism On The Web, 2005-2006.
You may reproduce most of our content on your own site provided you include a link back to us. This includes articles where we've received explicit permission from the author both to republish at Zionism On The Web and to pass this permission on to others. If you have articles on Zionism or Israel that you'd like us to share with others, please e-mail the content address below. If you have copyright questions please e-mail the webmaster. Thank you to all who have contributed their time and resources to ZionismOnTheWeb.org - Andre Oboler (Chief Executive) and the team at Zionism On The Web.

Mail the webmaster at: Please mail ZIONISTGUYS at the domain ZIONISMONTHEWEB.ORG
Mail potential content to: Please mail CONTENT at the domain ZIONISMONTHEWEB.ORG