Holocaust Denial and Facebook
Yes Facebook, it is Hate Speech
Navigation
Home > Antisemitism > here
Home > Articles > here
Boycotts of Israel
Academic Boycotts
Academics from Israel and the British Unions AUT and NATFHE (now UCU)
Anti-Zionist Academic Boycott Resources Center
Features include:
Share this page!
You can help us by sharing the contents on this page with others.
To help, please bookmark this and other pages you find useful with Facebook, Digg, del.icio.us, google, etc.
Thank you for your help, it does make a difference
Resources
- Articles on Zionism
- Zionism definition
- Christian Zionism
- Anti-Zionism
- Antisemitism
- Academic Boycotts
- Apartheid Libel
- Zionism Explained
- Misconceptions
- The Palestine state
- The Middle East
- Hackers against Israel
- Reference Material
Expert discussion
- General
- Media Watch
- M.E. Peace
- Israel's Security
- Zionism Discussion
- Antisemitism
- New Antisemitism
- Israel Boycotts
Expert Blogs
References
Further Information
Zionism Sources
Know what Zionism is, or only the propoganda?
When talking about people's political views the best bet is to ask them.
Articles Our collection on Zionism, Israel, and Anti-Zionism
Definitions A collection of definitions of Zionism
Zionism in brief A brief into to Zionism
Zionism Blog Discussion and commentary
Zionism and Me Resources from a personal perspective
Site information
Holocaust Denial: Yes Facebook, it is Hate Speech
By Andre Oboler, Z-Word Blog, 27 August 2009
My new report into Facebook and Holocaust denial has just been published. The report provides in-depth background and then delves into the reasons why Holocaust denial is hate speech, why counter speech is in this case not an option, and why Facebook as a private company does indeed have both the right and a moral obligation to remove this hateful content.
I first raised Holocaust denial as a form of antisemitism in social media in Online Anti-Semitism 2.0: Social Anti-Semitism on the Social Web, which was presented at the Global Forum to Combat Antisemitism in February 2008. In that paper antisemitism 2.0 is defined as “the use of online social networking and content collaboration to share demonization, conspiracy theories, Holocaust denial, and classical antisemitic motifs with a view to creating social acceptability for such content.”
The ultimate social acceptability of Holocaust denial was demonstrated when Randi Zuckerberg, Facebook’s marketing director (and sister of founder Mark Zuckerberg) spoke about “Facebook’s policy to not remove groups that deny the Holocaust.” Facebook had decided that hate was not acceptable but Holocaust denial in particular was ok.
This came after 9 months of dodging the issue, first in response to queries by German journalist Christoph Gunkel and then in responses to Brian Cuban and the JIDF. All three noted Facebook was in breach of German law and asked Facebook how they were going to responded. It was only when a story on CNET by Chris Matyszczyk (May 2009) triggered wide spread public interest that Facebook began to seriously respond.
Their response was to defend their right not to take action (unless legally required to) based on a “free speech” argument. This was supported by a change in Facebook’s term of use that few noticed amid the clamour around content ownership - part of the same extraordinary overhaul.
This was the first time Facebook systematically removed prohibitions on anti-social behaviour. On the chopping block were clauses preventing content that is “derogatory,” “demeaning,” “offensive,” “harmful,” “defamatory,” “abusive,” “inflammatory,” “vulgar,” “obscene,” “fraudulent,” “invasive of privacy or publicity rights,” or “racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable.” Also gone is the clause not to “violate any local, state, national or international law.”
The “Facebook Code of Conduct” was also removed. This is the document which stated “certain kinds of speech simply do not belong in a community like Facebook” and that “we want Facebook to be a safe place on the internet”. Facebook wants a change and it’s a pity they picked Holocaust denial as the place to try it out. It shows a lack of understanding of the nature of Holocaust denial.
The report goes on to discuss why Holocaust denial is hate speech, how it is treated in international law and politics and where Facebook’s various written responses fall short of the mark. The issue of the First Amendment (which does not apply as Facebook as a private company) and the First Amendment inspired answer of counter speech are also addressed. The report, Facebook, Holocaust Denial, and Anti-Semitism 2.0, is published by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs and available online.
Related articles
More articles on antisemitism:
Under attack in a virtual world
By Andre Oboler, PresenTense Magazine, Febuary 2010.Report from the Working Group on Online Antisemitism
By Andre Oboler and David Matas (Eds), The Global Forum to COmbat Antisemitism, December 2009, Jerusalem.Facebook, Holocaust Denial, and Anti-Semitism 2.0
By Andre Oboler, The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 15 September 2009. This is the detailed report (published online in August 2009).'Facebook doesn't bar hateful content against Jews'
By Elan Miller, Jerusalem Post, 27 August 2009Holocaust Denial: Yes Facebook, it is Hate Speech
By Andre Oboler, Z-Word Blog, 27 August 2009.Facebook gives hatred a hand
By Andre Oboler, Comment is Free at the Guardian, 13 July 2009Facebook refuses to ban all Holocaust-denial groups
By Chantal Abitbol, The Australian Jewish News, 15 May 2009, pg 8Antisemitism and the rise of a new world order? Obama’s inauguration
By Clemens Heni, Zionism On The Web, Febuary 7, 2009Iran, Holocaust denial and PressTV
By Andre Oboler, Zionism On The Web Special Report, December 4 2008Expert Warns on Internet antisemitism
By Sharon Berger, The Australian Jewish News, October 31 2008, pg 410 Questions for Dr Andre Oboler
The Australian Jewish News, October 31 2008, Life pg 16Facebook and Google Earth: Anti-Semitism in Web 2.0
By Christoph Gunkel and translated into English by Ricarda Krenn. Originaly Published in German as Christoph Gunkel, Facebook und Google Earth: Antisemitismus im Web 2.0, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ), Germany, 14 October 2008.Goldsmiths, Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto
By Jonathan Hoffman, Open Letter, Nov 13th 2008"But I am a Zionist!"
By Clemens Heni, Zionism On The Web, Nov 3rd 2008Good news in the fight against online hate
By Andre Oboler, Zionism On The Web, Sept 11, 2008. Original Draft (in English) of "Hatred and Antisemitism Online", Agencia Judia NoticiasHatred and Antisemitism Online
By Andre Oboler, Agencia Judia Noticias (Jewish News Agency - Argentina), Sept 4 2008Online Antisemitism 2.0, Social Antisemitism on the Social Web
By Dr Andre Oboler, The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, March / April 2008Anti-Semitism 2.0 Going Largely Unchallenged
By Tamar Snyder, The New York Jewish Week, Febuary 20 2008A false prospectus on campus
By Dr Andre Oboler, The Guardian, Comment is Free, February 15 2008Facebook antisemitism: Facing the Facebook Dilemma
By Dr Andre Oboler, Jerusalem Post, 6th February 2008Abusing the Holocaust
By Prof Gerald Steinberg, NGO-MonitorUK's NUS accepts EU Definition of Antisemitism
By Andre Oboler, A ZOTW SpecialEuropean Union Definition of Antisemitism
This is the definition used throughout Europe by law enforcementAntisemitism or anti-semitism?
By Andre Oboler, a ZOTW SpecialWhere Europe Fails
By Prof Gerald Steinberg, Jerusalem Post, 9 May 2007Hitler's Legacy: Islamic Antisemitism in the Middle East
By Dr Matthias Küntzel, a German political scientist and authorThe New Antisemitism
By Sir Jonathan Sacks, Chief Rabbi of the British Commonwealth of Nations. Read comments or add your own on the New Antisemitism forum.What's New In Anti-Semitism?
By Azmi Bishara (Arab-Israeli MK), Dar Al-Hayat, November 20, 2003The U.N. discovers the cause of anti-Semitism: Jews
By ANNE BAYEFSKY, Opinion Journal, November 18, 2004Aren't Arabs Semites too?
Analysis of the propoganda that Arabs are semites too and hence can't be antisemiticLanguage as a Tool against Jews and Israel
By Prof. Georges-Elia Sarfati, a French linguistics expertMuslim antisemitism and anti-Zionism explained
By Dr Denis M. MacEoin, an expert in Islamic studiesTop articles in the Antisemitism Forum Archive
You can visit our full collection for more articles on Zionism, Israel and Palestine
External article links
Arabs and antisemitism
The Wikipedia article on Arabs and antisemitism"Jew"
A Zionism Israel Information Center article on antisemitism and the Jews
External sites about antisemitism
The Coordination Forumfor Countering Antisemitism
JAFI resources on Antisemitism
International Center for the Study of Antisemitism At the Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Key references
The following may help you identify antisemitism and other types of racism
EU definition of antisemitism
Used by law enforcement throughout EuropeBehind much criticism of Israel is a thinly veiled hatred of Jews
Emanuele Ottolenghi, in The Guardian on Saturday November 29, 2003A New Antisemitism
Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks, June 2002Blurring the line
Fair critisism or antisemitism? By Abraham H. Foxman, National Director of the Anti-Defamation League (the ADL), in Haaretz on April 4, 2004Antisemitism in 3-D
Differentiating legitimate criticism of Israel from the so-called new anti-Semitism. By Natan Sharansky in Jerusalem Post, on February 23, 2004Anti-Zionism
What is Anti-Zionism?
Disagreeing with the policies of the Israeli government is in and of itself neither Antisemitic nor Anti-Zionist.
Even outside of this Anti-Zionism is not always Antisemitism, but many of those who claim to be anti-Zionist are in fact in fact peddling re-badged Antisemitism.
Our reference center can help you understand Anti-Zionism
Features include:
Originally published at Z-Word Blog (c) 2009 Andre Oboler
for an additional link on our links page.